Do Shock Collars Work On Aggressive Dogs? Yes, With Positive Reinforcement In 2023

Do you own an aggressive doggy? You might have heard about shock collars or e-collars that are most commonly used to train them and calm them down. But do shock collars work on aggressive dogs? Or it is just a myth? 

The answer to this question is yes! Shock collars work surprisingly well on aggressive dogs however, they need to be used properly when training a dog. This is because there are several factors due to which there could be negative outcomes. 

There are a lot of variables that as a responsible dog owner you should be aware of. This article answers the question, i.e. working of shock collars on aggressive dogs, with utmost detail. 

In addition to this, we will also talk about the negative effects of these collars on dogs so that you can learn when to use them and when to avoid them. 

How Does a Dog Shock Collar Work?

Before asking yourself a question: are shock collars effective for aggressive dogs? It is indispensable to learn about the working mechanism of dog shock collars. 

Once you understand how things work you will be able to understand and actually decide whether you should consider shock collar training for aggressive dogs or not. 

With that said let’s take a look at the basic principle behind a dog’s E-Collar!

As the name suggests, a shock collar, also known as an electronic shock collar, is a device that delivers an electric shock to your dog’s neck. 

This is mainly used as a punishment and helps signal the dog whatever he is up to or has done something is wrong. 

There are different types of shock collars available on the market. Some of them can be controlled with a remote controller while some of them have sensors that can actually sense your dog’s behavior and then deliver a shock accordingly. 

It usually consists of metal contact points that rest on the dog’s skin all the time. These contact points are powered by a steady current source that can generate and deliver somewhere around 1500 volts to 4500 volts of potential. 

This is enough to punish an aggressive dog not only one time but also to help change its behavior. 

Dogs are very intelligent creatures and they can be trained to do a lot of stuff. For example, if you reward them while asking them to do something they will recognize the world and will associate them with the treat. 

The same is the case with shock collars, when a dog shows aggression and gets zapped by the collar it learns being aggressive is not a good thing. 

Does Shock Collar Work For Aggressive Dog?

So will a shock collar stop a dog from being aggressive?

They contain tiny batteries, that’s why you might be asking to confirm right? 

Dog collars do work on aggressive dogs and they are effectively used for this purpose to train them. If your dog is showing aggressive behavior it may take some time to train him or her properly. 

However, sometimes things can go really out of the hand, and under such conditions, your furry friend can cause harm to others. In order to stop it from biting people and hurting other nearby fellows experts have devised an intelligent solution. 

They have introduced special collars which consist of batteries and a shocking mechanism that signals your pooch who’s the boss here, and how much it takes to be an aggressive boy here. When it comes to understanding how much they work there is a lot of evidence that will satisfy you.

If your dog is aggressive and you can’t control it with friendly reinforcement, then you should definitely get him a shock collar. But always use it for a short period of time with positive reinforcement.

Here is a list of the best and safe shock collars for big aggressive dogs like Pitbulls, check the buying guide before getting one.

Do Shock Collars Help With Aggression?

If your doggo is showing some aggression there is a high chance it will start growling. 

This is a signal that either you should be prepared for an attack or you have a few seconds to back off. 

If things go wrong or you don’t really get to understand its language the next thing that you should expect is aggression from the dog. 

Now you might be wondering whether a shock collar can help control such kind of situation or not. There are actually studies conducted by professional researchers in order to confirm the effectiveness of e-collars on dogs to fix their aggressive behavior.

However, according to most psychologists and experts, you should avoid using shock collars on your dogs. But there are some safe training collars, which you can consider while training your dog.

If you use passive reinforcement like here explained by Bill Hillmann thanks to him. Then you can see some good results even with aggressive dogs.

More Information About Shock Collars And Dog Training:


Do Shock Collars Make Dogs Aggressive?

A lot of people are concerned about the behavior of their dogs seriously. You might be wondering: will a shock collar make my dog more aggressive? 

As much as the dog collar is good for the dog’s behavior, too many shocks can turn the situation actually bad. This is because it can hurt the dog’s esteem and make them think that they are weak. 

Instead of teaching them about acceptable behaviors, shock collars when used too much can negatively affect your dog’s psychology. As a result, this can lead to depression, anxiety, and even more aggression. 

This is because dogs are natural fighters and they will always fight in return if they feel threatened. This means when you are using too many shocks on your dog this will trigger their negative behavior and they will think that everything is going to hurt them. 

Will Shock Collars Stop Dogs From Fighting?

We all have seen dogs fighting with each other and we know how terrifying it can be. But what about shock collars? Can they prevent them and stop the fight?

The answer to this question is both yes and no. So technically it depends on the situation. If both dogs wear a collar then it is possible to teach them fighting is not a good thing. 

However, if only one of them is wearing then the situation can turn into a horrific one. This is because one dog will try to back off while the other one will show complete aggression. Under such conditions, the dog wearing a collar can get hurt really badly and sometimes even die. 

Training Aggressive Dogs With Shock Collar:

Training Aggressive Dogs With Shock Collar

When it comes to training an aggressive dog with a shock collar there are a few things that you need to keep in mind. Keeping these things in mind will reinforce that your dog stays safe and learns the lesson well. 

  1. Do not tighten the collar too much. If the strap is too tight then it will make your dog uncomfortable.
  2. Avoid using shock collars with prongs. If the dog is too powerful the collar with prongs can damage its discs. 
  3. Tight collars can damage your dog’s larynx.
  4. It can also result in a bruised esophagus.
  5. Using a shock collar all the time will hurt the dog psychologically.

These are some of the things that you need to keep in mind when choosing a shock collar for your dog and deciding whether you should use it or not. 

Is Using a Shock Collar Cruel?

Another question that may come to your mind is whether using a shock collar is a cruel thing to do or not. The answer to this question is no. You should know that you are not torturing your doggo but helping him to reduce his aggression and learn something positive. 

Using a shock collar allows you to train your dog well if he or she is not listening to you or learning something just by giving them treats. However, it becomes cruel when you are using it too much or using a collar with prongs. 

Such types of collars can hurt your dog in multiple ways. The first and most obvious reason is that the prongs can interfere with the dog’s neck which can disturb his vertebral discs. Apart from that, it can also result in choking if the dog is strong and he or she wants to move away. 

FAQs

What To Do With A Dog Aggressive Dog?

If your dog is showing aggression be sure to treat him properly such as avoiding giving him his favorite treat and saying bad do. If the problem persists consult a specialized dog trainer. 

How Do Vets Calm Aggressive Dogs?

There are multiple ways through which vets calm aggressive dogs. These methods include giving him a collar, anxiety medication & sedatives, pheromones, or behavior modification such as desensitization and counterconditioning. 

How To Stop Dog Aggression Towards Other Dogs?

Dogs are naturally aggressive toward each other. However, this aggression can be reduced by introducing them to each other gradually. However, if the aggression continues then you should use dog shock collars to signal them. 

Why Is My Dog Aggressive To Other Dogs On Walks?

As mentioned earlier, dogs are aggressive towards other dogs naturally. However, there could be some other reasons behind this. One of the most common reasons behind aggression is direct eye contact between your dog and other dogs. 

Can Shock Collars Make Dogs Aggressive?

Yes, shock collars make them aggressive because dogs are naturally reactive toward threats. They retaliate properly whenever they feel threatened. However, if used moderately then shock collars can help keep things positive.

Leave a Comment