Can You Potty Train A Dog With A Shock Collar In 2023

If you’ve been struggling to get your pup to use the bathroom outside, you may be wondering can you potty train a dog with a shock collar?

Shock collars are one of the most controversial training tools on the market. Some argue that they’re inhumane and can cause psychological damage, while others claim they’re an effective way to train dogs. So, what’s the truth? Shock Collar potty training is not a good idea (if not used with positive reinforcement).

In this blog post, we’ll go through whether can you use a shock collar for potty training. Do vets approve of shock collars? and Why you shouldn’t use shock collars on dogs? So, let’s get started!

Can You Potty Train A Dog With A Shock Collar? Why Research Is Against It?

There are some occasions when are just itching to yell at our dogs because of their actions. One of the most common (and frustrating!) ones is when they refuse to potty train. It seems like no matter what you do, your dog just won’t go to the bathroom outside.

If you’re at your wit’s end, you may be wondering wether can a shock collar help with potty training. Unfortunately, the answer is no. Shock collars are not a good idea for potty training (or any other type of training).

In fact, most veterinarians will tell you to avoid them altogether. Not only are shock collars cruel, but they can also cause your dog to become scared of you and mistrustful of other people.

In addition to that, shock collars can actually make behavioral problems worse. For example, if your dog is already anxious, a shock collar could make them even more stressed and fearful.

Research

✔ According to the research by Humane Society International, 
"The use of shock collars on dogs has been linked to increased anxiety and stress levels in dogs." 
So, if you're thinking about using a shock collar to potty train your dog; we urge you to reconsider, or at least use it with a positive reinforcement. There are also more peaceful, effective strategies to teach your dog.

Other Guides About Training And Shock Collars:

Here are some other guides about shock collars and training your dogs, make sure to check them out:


Why You Shouldn’t Use Shock Collars On Dogs?

Shock collars work by delivering a brief electric shock to your dog whenever they misbehave. The idea is that your dog will link the shock with the unpleasant behavior, and he or she will stop doing it.

While this may work in the short term, it’s not a long-term solution. In fact, it can actually make the behavioral issues worse. Shock collars can cause your dog to become scared of you and mistrustful of other people.

In addition, shock collars can actually make behavioral problems worse. So, if you’re potty training your dog, do yourself (and your dog) a favor and skip the shock collar. In fact, it is possible to train your pooch in a much better, effective, and more humane way.

Better Way To Potty Train A Dog

If you’re looking for a kinder, gentler way to potty train your dog, we recommend positive reinforcement training. This form of training is based on the use of incentives (such as snacks or praises) to elicit desired behavior. It’s not only more compassionate, but it also works better in the long run.

If you’re still set on using a shock collar as an alternative option, we strongly recommend seeking out the help of a professional trainer first. They can instruct you on how to correctly use the collar and avoid any potential problems that might result in an unnecessary situation to remedy.

Tips To Potty Train A Dog

Here are some tips to potty train your dog, without a shock collar:

1. Start With A Small Area.

If your dog is having trouble going potty outside, start by confining them to a small area (like a bathroom). This will assist them to link peeing in this area with the action.

2. Using A Cue Word Is Beneficial.

When you take your dog out to go potty, use a cue word or phrase (like “go potty”). This will assist them in understanding what you want from them.

3. Be Consistent In Your Approach.

When instructing your dog to pee and poo outside, it’s important to be consistent. Take them out at the same time each day and use the same cue word every time.

4. Reward Good Behavior.

When your dog goes to pee in the designated area, make sure to praise them and give them a treat. This may assist them to realize that going to the toilet outdoors is a good thing by reinforcing positive conduct.

5. Take A Positive Approach.

Punishing your dog may only make the situation worse. If they have an accident inside, simply clean it up and move on. If it still doesn’t work then you may go towards e-collar training (But Always Use A Positive Approach).

As long as you follow these suggestions, your dog should have no trouble learning how to pee and poo in the toilet. Now let’s check out, what are the problems that dog owners usually face when they use the shock collar to potty train a dog.

Problems With The Use Of Shock Collar To Potty Train A Dog

There are several flaws with employing a shock collar for dog peeing or pooping in the house to train it to go outside.

  • The first issue is that dogs aren’t always aware of the link between the shock and the behavior. They may just think that you’re randomly shocking them for no reason. This can lead to mistrust and even fear.
  • Second, even if your dog does make the connection, they may just learn to avoid whatever it is you’re trying to get them to do. For example, if you’re trying to potty train your dog with a shock collar, they may just start holding it in all the time instead of going outside. This can lead to medical problems like bladder infections.
  • Lastly, shock collars can actually make behavioral problems worse. Dogs that are already anxious or fearful may become even more so when they’re constantly being shocked.
Infection Caused By Shock Collar:
It's one of the worse side effects or infections caused by the accessive use of shock collars, known as Pressure Necrosis or Pressure Sores in dogs. 
The symptoms includes the pressure sores and reddish marks on dogs neck.
So, always try to put the shock collar on your dogs for a short time and if any pressure necrosis happens to your dog then don't worry, we have got you covered for the home-based treatment. Check this article for pressure necrosis treatment at home.

So, what’s the bottom line?

A shock collar is not a good idea for potty training. If your dog is very aggressive and you still want to use it anyway, then use it with the positive reinforcement method.

If you’re having trouble potty training your dog, talk to your pup’s veterinarian about humane and effective alternatives.

Why Do Dogs Poop In The House After Being Outside?

After being outside, dogs may poop in the house for a variety of causes. They may have eaten something that made them sick or they might be ill. If your dog has never pooped in the house before, it is important to take him to the vet to rule out any medical problems. If he is in good health, there are a few things you can try to stop this weird behavior.

Smaller meals should be fed to your dog more frequently throughout the day. This will help his digestive system and may prevent him from having an urge to go while he is outside. You should also make sure he has plenty of opportunities to relieve himself before taking him inside. If he has been playing or exercising, give him a chance to go before coming back inside.

If your dog is defecating inside after going outside, you must clean up the mess promptly. Leaving them will only encourage him to do it again. You may also want to try using a crate or baby gate to keep him indoors when you can’t watch him. This will prevent him from having access to the outdoors where he can relieve himself.

It is also important to praise your dog when he goes potty outside. This will reinforce the behavior you want and help him to associate going potty with positive things. You should be able to prevent your dog from defecating in the house after going outside if you have enough patience and consistency.

How Do You Respond When A Dog Poops In The House?

If your dog has an accident inside, the best thing you can do is clean it up and move on. Yelling at your dog or chastising them will only make the issue worse. They won’t understand why they’re being yelled at, and they’ll be frightened or tense.

Instead, encourage them to go potty outside more frequently and give them positive feedback when they do so. With time and patience, your pet will realize that they are only supposed to go potty outdoors.

What Is The Hardest Dog To Potty Train?

There is no true way to know how long it takes dogs to potty train. Some dogs may be simple to potty train, but others might be more difficult. All you can really do is your best to ensure your dog will learn using the techniques which have proven most effective for other dogs.

Some of the factors that can make potty training more difficult include a dog’s age, temperament, and previous experiences.

Puppies are typically easier to potty train than adult dogs. And, dogs that have had bad experiences with going potty (like being scolded or punished) may be more resistant to learning.

For example, if you’re having trouble potty training your Poodle, talk to a professional. They are big dogs that need lots of attention and patience. Try talking to a veterinarian or a dog trainer for help. Professional trainers can assess your dog’s individual needs based on breed and tell you the best course of action to take.

How Do You Potty Train A Stubborn Dog?

If you’re having trouble potty training your dog (your pup is a very stubborn one), you may be considering using a shock collar to help teach them where to go. But is this really the best idea?

Shock collars are often used as a last resort for dog trainers, and with good reason. They can be very effective in getting a dog’s attention and stopping unwanted behavior, but they can also cause a great deal of stress and anxiety. If not used properly, shock collars can even lead to aggression.

So, before you decide to use a shock collar to potty train your dog, make sure you’ve tried all the other methods first. If you do decide to go ahead with it, start with the lowest setting possible and only use it when absolutely necessary. And, as always, consult with a professional trainer if you have any concerns.

Safe Shock Collar For Dogs:

Well you’re still reading this post and I’m reading your mind, you think that “Alright, shock collars are bad. But my dog is out of control and a bit wild, she can’t be trained with other training methods”.

Ok, I can understand. And you know what this is almost the god parent’s fault, they give their babies that much love so they become uncivilized and wild. They don’t obey any order then.

But hay, let me tell you, there are still some kinds of shock collars available that are completely safe for dogs if you use them the right way. They don’t directly shock them with current, but they have a few features like Beep, Vibration, and then shock.

So, if you are searching for that kind of collar that will not shock your dog on the spot, but will just warn her with a beep of vibration, that will also be in your control because of the remote controller. Then I have a good option for you which I sometimes use with my Husky (She every time disobeys, but the Labrador is very nice and innocent).

The Delupet's Dog Shock Collar. Safe shock collar for dogs.
The safest Shock Collar

The Delupet’s Dog Shock Collar is very safe in such a way. It has the same three stages system like beep, vibrate and shock. It has a remote controller, so whenever your pup do a mistake then you can just warn her with a beep if she does it again then give her a bit of vibration. But if she does it repeatedly then let her test the bitterness of electric shock, because everything is for her well-being at the end of the day.

This collar can operate within a 1600ft area and has a good IPX7 waterproof receiver if your dog plays around the pool or any water tap etc. This has a comfortable neck bend or collar for long-time comfort for your pup. I’d suggest not letting them wear for more than 7 to 8 hours continuously. This also has a safety lock in the remote controller, so you will not shock your pup accidentally. It has a built-in led display for ease during nighttime and has about 35 days of battery backup (Tested myself).

Conclusion

If you are thinking about whether can you potty train a dog with a shock collar, then read the above article.

Shock collars are not a good idea for potty-training dogs. We suggest using a shock collar only as a last resort, which still may not be the best solution, and that all other methods should be tried first.

Because shock collars can cause mistrust, fear, and anxiety, and may even make behavioral problems worse, if not used with positive reinforcement I mean cruelly.

Remember, whenever you think of using a shock collar with your dog, then use it with positive reinforcement.

We’ve covered all the difficulties of potty training a dog and provided solutions to them. In addition to that, we’ve also provided some very useful tips for potty training a dog. By following our tips, you should have no problem potty training your dog in no time. Thanks for reading!

FAQs

Q: How do you stop a puppy from peeing and pooping in the house?

A: The best way to stop a puppy from peeing and pooping in the house is to take them outside frequently and praise them when they go potty in the designated spot. With time and patience, your dog will learn that it should only go potty outside.

Q: Do vets approve of shock collars?

A: While shock collars may be effective in getting a dog’s attention and stopping unwanted behavior, they can also cause a great deal of stress and anxiety. If not used properly, shock collars can even lead to aggression. That’s why vets typically only approve of using them as a last resort.

Q: What age are most puppies potty trained?

A: Most puppies are potty trained by 6 months of age. However, some may take longer depending on individual factors such as temperament and previous experiences.

Q: How long after puppy eats do they poop?

A: Generally, puppies will poop 15-30 minutes after they eat. However, this can vary depending on the individual dog and how much they’ve eaten.

Leave a Comment